6th Circuit Court of Appeals Holds Employe to Pay for J-1 Waiver and H-1B Visa

6th Circuit Court of Appeals Upholds J-1 Waiver as a Business Expense 

Sixth Circuit

December 5, 2014


In Kutty v. United States Dep’t of Labor, a doctor, owner of a clinic, filed a complaint against the Department of Labor claiming that he should not be liable to pay for J-1 waiver. The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the argument of Administrative Review Board (ARB, a branch of the Department of Labor) that J-1 waiver is by law a business expense, thus, should be paid by the employer. Any attempt to receive “reimbursement” from employees for H-1B visa application or J-1 waiver would make employers liable for back wages. The court held that costs, including attorneys’ fees, of obtaining H-1B visas were business expenses within the meaning of 20 C.F.R.§655.731(c)(9)(iii)(C). Therefore, the court disposed the case and opined that the petitioner clinic owner is liable for both back wages and potentially civil penalties.

In support of the disposition and holding, the Court also ruled that the evidence presented by Department of Labor did not abuse its discretion or act arbitrarily in ordering the clinic to pay back wages.

Lastly, the court found the circumstance sufficient to justify holding the clinic owner liable to pay back wages based on the following factors,

“. . . (1) whether there was a failure to collect paid in capital; (2) whether the corporation was grossly undercapitalized; (3) the nonissuance of stock certificates; (4) the sole ownership of stock by one individual; (5) the use of the same office or business location; (6) the employment of the same employees or attorneys; (7) the use of the corporation as an instrumentality or business conduit for an individual or another corporation; (8) the diversion of corporate assets by or to a stockholder or other entity to the detriment of creditors, or the manipulation of assets and liabilities in another; (9) the use of the corporation as a subterfuge in illegal transactions; (10) the formation and use of the corporation to transfer to it the existing liability of another person or entity; and (11) the failure to maintain arms length relationships among related entities.” Kutty v. United States Dep’t of Labor, 764 F.3d 540, 554.

Kutty hired seventeen physicians in Tennessee and maintained a web of corporate entities to hire nonimmigrant entities. Majority of the factors were met. The Circuit Court, thus, held that Kutty could be held liable to back wages as the sole proprietor.

A lesson for other immigrants is—please check whether your employer can legally require you to indirectly pay for H-1B status or J-1 waiver application. The court clearly said no to employer’s attempt to recover payments for procedures mandated to be paid by business owner. Consult a trustworthy immigrant lawyer, should you find issues of this kind to surface in your life.


 

About the author

Richard Herman Richard Herman is a nationally-known immigration attorney with 20+ years of experience representing families and businesses in all aspects of immigration law. Richard was voted for inclusion in the 2015 edition of The Best Lawyers in America© and listed in Super Lawyers© for ten consecutive years, Richard is the founder of the Herman Legal Group, an immigration law firm serving clients in over 12 languages from offices in Cleveland, Columbus and Detroit, whose attorneys have represented diverse clientele, from Fortune 500 companies to undocumented workers, from technology entrepreneurs to NFL teams. He is the co-author of the acclaimed book, Immigrant, Inc. ---Why Immigrant Entrepreneurs Are Driving the New Economy (John Wiley & Sons, 2009). Richard has appeared FOX News (The O’Reilly Factor), ABC News 20/20, National Public Radio, and has appeared in the New York Times, USA Today, BusinessWeek, Forbes, Inc., PC World, Computerworld, CIO, TechCrunch and InformationWeek.

Related Posts

Juvenile Criminal Records and Immigration Benefits

Juvenile Criminal Records and Immigration Benefits
2017-03-20 12:24:58
richardherman

18

Does Your Lawyer Understand the Immigration Issue?

Does Your Lawyer Understand the Immigration Issue?
2015-11-23 05:53:24
richardherman

18

Norwalk-Sandusky Ohio Immigration Attorneys

Richard T. Herman is a Norwalk-Sandusky Ohio immigration attorney who has spent the over 20 years representing
2015-07-01 14:46:08
richardherman

18

Cities and Counties Welcome Immigrants!

Cities and Counties Welcome Immigrants!
2015-04-06 15:09:37
richardherman

18

波 兰 籍( Poland ) 雇 员 获 得 绿 卡

Poland Employee Granted Green Card Based on Work
2015-04-01 20:09:27
richardherman

18

泰 国 (Thailand )籍 配 偶 获 得 永 久 居 住 权

Thailand Spouse Granted Green Card
2015-03-25 19:30:19
richardherman

18

Remand to BIA: Crime of Moral Turpitude

Remanded to BIA for Further Consideration
2015-01-06 19:41:28
richardherman

18

Immigration Offices: USCIS Cleveland, Columbus, Detroit, Pittsburgh

The U.S. Citizenship & Immigration Service has offices in Columbus, Cleveland, Detroit and Pittsburgh. At these
2014-12-29 03:45:01
richardherman

18

Immigration Lawyers in Cleveland, Ohio

Are you looking for a lawyer to represent you or a member of your family in an immigration matter?  You are invited to
2014-12-09 18:14:29
richardherman

18

Immigration Reform and Grave Consequence of Fumbling This Time

Immigration Reform for Real: This Time, Democrats
2014-11-19 18:07:50
richardherman

18

The following two tabs change content below.
Richard Herman is a nationally-known immigration attorney with 20+ years of experience representing families and businesses in all aspects of immigration law. Richard was voted for inclusion in the 2015 edition of The Best Lawyers in America© and listed in Super Lawyers© for ten consecutive years, Richard is the founder of the Herman Legal Group, an immigration law firm serving clients in over 12 languages from offices in Cleveland, Columbus and Detroit, whose attorneys have represented diverse clientele, from Fortune 500 companies to undocumented workers, from technology entrepreneurs to NFL teams. He is the co-author of the acclaimed book, Immigrant, Inc. ---Why Immigrant Entrepreneurs Are Driving the New Economy (John Wiley & Sons, 2009). Richard has appeared FOX News (The O’Reilly Factor), ABC News 20/20, National Public Radio, and has appeared in the New York Times, USA Today, BusinessWeek, Forbes, Inc., PC World, Computerworld, CIO, TechCrunch and InformationWeek.

Latest posts by Richard Herman (see all)

0 Comments

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*